In recent MotoGP discussions, Ducati Team Manager Davide Tardozzi made a statement that has sparked both intrigue and debate among fans and analysts alike. Tardozzi voiced his admiration for Francesco “Pecco” Bagnaia, describing the Italian’s recent performances as not only impressive but also, in his opinion, surpassing the achievements of Casey Stoner. The legendary Australian, who brought Ducati its first MotoGP world title in 2007, remains a revered figure in the sport. However, Tardozzi’s praise for Bagnaia raised questions about how Stoner himself views this comparison, especially considering Stoner’s well-known competitive spirit and pride in his own legacy.
In his response, Stoner showed a complex mix of respect for Bagnaia’s abilities and a natural competitive pride. While he acknowledged the impressive form of Bagnaia and the achievements that Tardozzi is celebrating, Stoner did not shy away from expressing his belief that his own time with Ducati remains unique. “It’s true that Pecco has shown fantastic skill and confidence on the bike, and I’m delighted to see Ducati performing so well. But to say he’s outclassing me? That might be a stretch,” Stoner said. His tone reflected both admiration for Bagnaia and a reminder of the challenges Stoner faced during his tenure.
Stoner’s Legacy at Ducati: A Benchmark for Bagnaia
Stoner’s history with Ducati is deeply embedded in the team’s legacy. In 2007, he delivered the first-ever MotoGP World Championship title to Ducati, overcoming an era dominated by Honda and Yamaha. Stoner’s triumph was considered a watershed moment in MotoGP, particularly because he excelled on a bike often seen as notoriously difficult to control. His 2007 championship season was marked by spectacular performances, bold overtakes, and an impressive mental fortitude that allowed him to fend off competitors like Valentino Rossi.
The success of Bagnaia, however, reflects a different era of MotoGP, where Ducati’s engineering has evolved, making their bikes much more competitive. Tardozzi’s remark that Bagnaia “outclasses” Stoner is rooted in the Italian’s recent success with a more refined Ducati, benefiting from years of advancement and development. This is not to undermine Bagnaia’s abilities, as he has undoubtedly capitalized on the resources available, but to Stoner, comparing the two might be an oversimplification. “We’re talking about very different machines and very different times,” he added, explaining how his Ducati experience was unique.
Bagnaia’s Rise and Why it ‘Bothers’ Stoner
Bagnaia’s ascent to MotoGP stardom has indeed been remarkable. After securing the 2022 MotoGP World Championship, he showed both resilience and consistency, which Tardozzi believes exemplifies his top-tier status. Stoner has taken notice, particularly as Bagnaia now has Ducati’s backing in a way that the Australian might have wished for during his time with the team.
When asked about seeing Bagnaia in second place or trailing, Stoner admitted, “It does bother me.” He went on to explain that this is not from a place of rivalry, but from a sense of wanting to see the Ducati name consistently at the top. “Once you’re a part of something like that, you want to see it succeed,” Stoner said, revealing his strong ties to the Ducati legacy. He has a personal investment in seeing the red bike dominate, which perhaps explains his frustration when he witnesses any struggles.
Stoner’s sentiments reveal his underlying attachment to the team’s journey. Despite no longer being an active racer, his heart remains with Ducati. His hope is for the team to achieve what he could not on a more consistent basis. “It’s a different feeling when you’ve been part of that journey. I know how much Ducati fans want to see those wins,” he added.
Tardozzi’s Optimism for Bagnaia and the Future of Ducati
For Tardozzi, Bagnaia represents the future of Ducati racing—a rider who not only has the skill but also the temperament to keep pushing the team forward. Tardozzi’s assertion that Bagnaia “outclasses” Stoner reflects his belief in Bagnaia’s potential to continue setting records. He values how Bagnaia’s personality and work ethic align well with the team’s philosophy and his recent title defenses affirm Ducati’s place in the modern MotoGP landscape.
Ducati’s support for Bagnaia is a significant point of pride, and Tardozzi is particularly pleased with the team’s progression in offering a competitive package. “Pecco is a brilliant rider and ambassador for the team,” Tardozzi remarked, pointing to Bagnaia’s role in bolstering Ducati’s reputation internationally. Stoner himself has acknowledged Bagnaia’s skill, remarking, “I respect what he’s doing, and it’s exciting to watch,” although he maintains that his own journey with Ducati was unique.
Reflecting on the Comparison and Stoner’s Perspective on Legacy
The comparison between Stoner and Bagnaia may be exciting for fans and Ducati insiders, but Stoner approaches the debate with a balanced perspective. “It’s flattering to still be part of the conversation,” he said, reflecting on the years since his retirement. Stoner remains proud of his time with Ducati and the contributions he made, while recognizing that Bagnaia’s achievements deserve celebration. “I want the best for Ducati, and if that means someone surpasses what I did, so be it,” he stated.
In sum, Stoner’s reaction to Tardozzi’s comments is rooted in both admiration and a grounded sense of realism. Stoner acknowledges Bagnaia’s talent and appreciates the progress Ducati has made, yet he retains a firm sense of his own contributions and the unique challenges he faced. While Bagnaia is indeed a formidable force in MotoGP, Stoner’s place in Ducati’s history remains unparalleled in his view.
